South Cave Parish Council
Planning Meeting 5th July 2010
The Meeting of South Cave Parish Council Planning Committee took place in the Town Hall, Market Place, South Cave at 7.30pm.
Present: Cllrs Harrison (Chairman), Barnett, M Turner, L Turner, Kelly, Marsh, Jamieson, Lenton and Munby
Mrs K Cooper Clerk
8 members of the public
Cllr Manley proposed that apologies for absence be accepted from Cllr Wright, Seconded Cllr
Marsh, All in favour.
Cllr Lenton declared personal and prejudicial interests in item number 1696 (iv) due to being a
neighbour, personal friend and having involvement in the plans.
Cllr Manley declared a personal interest in item numbers 1696 (iv) and (vi) due to friendship.
1695 Decisions made by East Riding of Yorkshire Council
(i)DC/10/00974 & 00976/PLF/WESTES Erection of a single storey extension to rear
and reconstruction of garage to re-orientate access at Old Priory, 8 Station Road, South
Cave - Granted with conditions (No obj)
The Planning Committee noted the above decisions by ERYC.
1696 Current Plans to consider
The meeting was closed at 7.05pm for members of the public to address the Parish Council
regarding the following item. The meeting reconvened at 7.10pm
(i)DC/10/01948/PLF/WESTES (Amended Plans) Full Planning Permission
Erection of dwelling at Land North of 91 Beverley Road, South Cave for Mr & Mrs Holbrook.
Cllr M Turner proposed that the Parish Council continue to recommend refusal of this application due to height, massing and dominance of the proposed dwelling which is in a prominent location at the entrance to the village. There are minimal changes to the amended plans other than reducing the ridge height, but the proposed property is larger. The north west elevation hall/landing window still overlooks plot 2, Seconded Cllr Barnett, Vote: 10 for, 1 abstention.
The following item (vi) was moved forward on the agenda to be discussed second and the meeting was closed at 7.15pm for members of the public to address the Parish Council with objections. The meeting reconvened at 7.20pm.
(vi)DC/10/02479/PLF/WESTES Full Planning Permission
Erection of first floor extension to side and rear at 19 Castle Rise, South Cave for Mr M Clark.
Cllr Lenton proposed that the Parish Council recommend refusal of this application due to overdevelopment, massing and dominance. The extension will have an adverse effect on surrounding properties and particularly no. 21 which will be put into complete shadow for most of the day in the already small back garden. It will have a detrimental effect on the street scene by in filling a gap which had originally been planned as chalet style houses with half garages and will spoil the character of this particular road, Seconded Cllr Marsh, All in favour.
The following item (v) was moved forward on the agenda to be discussed third and the meeting was closed at 7.25pm for a member of the public to address the Parish Council. The meeting reconvened at 7.30pm.
(v)DC/10/01775/VAR/WESTES Variation of Condition(s)
Removal of Condition 6 of planning permission 04/05840/PLF to allow the sale of hot food takeaway at the Gallery, 67 Market Place, South Cave for Ms G Edson.
Cllr Marsh proposed that the Parish Council raise no objection to the proposal, but with residents concerns of parking problems and noise, would like to suggest that a time restriction be placed on the permission to serve takeaway food of no later than 10.00pm and evenings only, Seconded Cllr Kelly, All in favour.
(ii)DC/10/01908//PLF/WESTES Full Planning Permission
Erection of 1 no. dwelling (Re-submission of 09/03926/PLF) at Land Rear of 62 Beverley Road, South Cave for Mrs E Christmas.
Cllr Marsh proposed that although the plans show a reduced roof space, the overall footprint of the property is exactly the same and would recommend the Parish Council refuse this application due to massing and dominance of this large proposal, which would be out of character with the surrounding bungalows and have a detrimental effect on the surrounding single dwellings along this side of Beverley Road which are set in large spacious gardens. Concerns have not been addressed regarding the narrow access road which currently services 5 properties and with planning permission already granted for a sixth, the Parish Council feel this road is not of sufficient standard and width to service any more properties, Seconded Cllr Barnett, All in favour.
(iii)DC/10/02263/PLF/WESTES Full Planning Permission
Erection of a replacement semi-detached dwelling at 4 Common Road, South Cave for Mr D Hurd.
Cllr L Turner proposed that the Parish Council raise no objections to the proposal as it has no adverse effect on the property, neighbouring property or the street scene, Seconded Cllr Marsh, All in favour.
Cllr Lenton left the meeting before discussion of the next item (iv).
(iv)DC/10/02446/PLF/WESTES Full Planning Permission
Erection of domestic garage/workshop and demolition of existing buildings at 21 West End, South Cave for Dr J Keel.
Cllr Marsh proposed that the Parish Council raise no objections to the proposal as it has no adverse effect on the property, the neighbouring properties, the street scene or the conservation area, Seconded Cllr Manley, All in favour.
Cllr Lenton returned to the meeting.
(vii)DC/10/01168/PLF/WESTES Full Planning Permission
Retention of a detached garage and gym to rear (AMENDED DESCRIPTION) at South Holme,
39 Beverley Road, South Cave for Mr M Brooker.
Cllr Marsh proposed that the Parish Council raise no objection but would like to recommend as
before, that because of the size of the garage/gym, ERYC include a stipulation that the gym is
for private use only, Seconded Cllr Lenton, All in favour.
1697 Trees Decisions
(i)The Planning Committee noted the letter received from ERYC regarding trees at Cave Castle.
(ii)App No. 10/60030/TPO Fell, remove and prunes trees at South Cave Primary School, Church Street, South Cave - Permission Granted.
(iii)App No. 10/50057/TCA Remove Leylandii tree at 1 Castle Drive, South Cave Permission Granted.
(iv)App No. 10/60067/TPO Oak Tree - Crown lift and reduce limb growing over garage, deadwood and thin crown by 25% at 7 The Stray, South Cave Permission Granted.
The Planning Committee noted the decisions made by East Riding of Yorkshire Council.