South Cave Parish Council

 

Planning Meeting 29th January 2007

 

The Planning Meeting of South Cave Parish Council took place in the Town Hall, Market Place, South Cave at 7.00pm.

 

Present:            Cllrs Turner, Mann, Scott, Lenton, Harrison, Marsh, Mrs Manley(Chair) and Mrs Binns

                        Mrs K Richmond – Clerk

                        12 Members of the Public

                       

1375  Apologies for absence

Cllr Mrs Manley proposed that apologies be accepted from Cllr Mrs Barnett, seconded Cllr Mann, All in favour.

Absent: Cllrs Hardy and Wright

 

1376   Approval of Previous Meeting's Minutes

The minutes of the meeting of 8th January 2007 were signed as a true and correct record proposed Cllr Marsh, seconded Cllr Mrs Binns, All in favour.

 

1377   Declarations of Interest

Cllr Mrs Binns declared a personal interest in minute reference: 1380 (ii) due to acquaintanceship

Cllr Mrs Manley declared a personal interest in minute reference: 1380 (iii) due to living on the same street as the application

Cllr Turner declared a personal interest in minute reference: 1380 (ii) due to living on the same street as the application

Cllr Lenton declared a prejudicial interest in minute reference: 1380 (iii) due to living in close proximity to the application

Cllr Harrison declared a prejudicial interest in minute reference: 1380 (iii) to friendship

 

1378    Correspondence

(i)The Council noted that DC/06/07460/PLF – change of use from agricultural land to private residential land at Pencoed, Common Road, South Cave, has been withdrawn

 

1379    Decisions made by the East Riding of Yorkshire Council

(i)DC/06/0662/PLF – Full Planning Permission

Erection of two dwellings following demolition of existing dwelling provision of additional vehicular access and alterations to levels on site and finished floor levels (resubmission of 06/01681/PLF) at 91 Beverley Road, South Cave – Refused

(ii)DC/06/06790/PLF – Full Planning Permission

Erection of a single storey extension to side of existing garage at 1 Church Hill, South Cave – Approved with conditions

(iii)DC/06/08081/PLF – Full Planning Permission

Erection of detached building to be used as stables at land north west of 38 Northfield Close, South Cave – Approved with conditions

 

 

Initialled………..

 

 

(iv)DC/06/08823/PLF – Full Planning Permission

Erection of two storey and single storey extensions to side and single storey extension to rear following demolition of existing extensions at 20 Bridge Road, South Cave – Approved with conditions.

(v)DC/06/09290/PLF – Full Planning Permission

Erection of a single storey extension to rear at 128 The Stray, South Cave – Approved with conditions.

 

1380    Current plans to consider

(i)DC/06/09540/PLF/WESTES – Full Planning Permission

Erection of a timber shed to rear of existing garage at 4 Radcliffe Garth, South Cave for Mr and Mrs R Cooper. Cllr Mrs Binns proposed that the Parish Council raises no objection to this application as it has no adverse effect on the property, neighbouring properties or the street scene, and also has no adverse effect on the character and appearance of the Conservation Area, seconded Cllr Turner, All in favour.

(ii)DC/06/09953/PLF/WESTES – Full Planning Permission

Erection of 1 single storey dwelling and 1 two  storey dwelling following demolition of existing sheds and conversation and alterations to existing shed to form single storey dwelling (amended scheme 06/06945/PLF at 48 West End, South Cave for Rok Design and Build. (four letters of objection and 1 petition received). Cllr Turner proposed that the Parish Council recommends refusal of this application for the following reasons:

(i)The two storey dwelling (plot 4) would look out over bungalows therefore creating overshadowing and overlooking, and would have an adverse effect on the street scene.

(2)There are considerable concerns regarding the access out onto Barnards Drive, as this proposed development would have an adverse effect on the enjoyment of neighbouring properties, would have a negative impact on road safety, as this is adjacent to a footpath used by school children.

(3)It is considered that there is insufficient parking on the site, leading to vehicles being parked along Barnards Drive cul-de-sac.

(4)There are also concerns raised over the treatment of the beck, as this stream is considered to be a flood risk and this development would potentially exacerbate the situation.

(5)The sewerage system within this area is not adequate for the number of houses, and this development would add to the problems already being experienced.

It was also suggested that part of the Design and Access Statement should include some reference to consultation with the neighbours, and this has not taken place; that these sheds may be a bat roost; and that there is asbestos in the buildings which will need to be disposed of in the correct manner, seconded Cllr Harrison, All in favour.

Cllrs Lenton and Harrison declared a prejudicial interest and left the meeting and room for the following item.

(iii)DC/06/09959/PLF/WESTES – Full Planning Permission

Erection of dwelling following demolition of existing dwelling (re-submission of 06/05263/PLF at 38 Northfield Close, South Cave for Mr and Mrs Dearnley (6 letters of objection received). Cllr Marsh proposed that Parish Council objects to the application, on the grounds of massing, dominance and overshadowing, having an adverse effect on the enjoyment of the neighbouring property, and would have a detrimental effect on the street scene due to scale, character and design, seconded Cllr Turner, All in favour. It was also reported that there may be some anomalies regarding the illustrations and plans as submitted.

 

 

 

Initialled…………

 

 

(iv)DC/06/10006/PLF/WESTES – Full Planning Permission

Erection of 1 dormer bungalow with integral garage at land south east of 72 Beverley Road, South Cave for Alliance General Property Developments. Cllr Lenton proposed that Parish Council raises no objection to this application as it has no adverse effect on the existing property, the neighbouring properties or the street scene; and would point out that there are inconsistencies within the tree report, and would like to ensure that there is adequate protection for tree stocks within this sensitive location, seconded Cllr Marsh, vote: 6 in favour 2 against.

(v)DC/07/00022/PCC/WESTES – Conservation Area Consent

Demolition of existing sheds at 48 West End, South Cave for Rok Design & Build. Cllr Lenton proposed that as there is no suitable replacement scheme, the Parish Council recommends refusal of this application, seconded Cllr Mrs Binns, All in favour. The LPA should also be advised that these sheds may be a bat roost.

(vi)DC/07/00123/PLF/WESTES – Full Planning Permission

Erection of detached garage at rear following demolition of existing at 12 Middle Garth Drive, South Cave for Mr Lamb.  Cllr Scott proposed that the Parish Council raise no objection as the application has no adverse effect on the property, neighbouring properties or the street scene, seconded Cllr Lenton, All in favour.

(vii)DC/07/00171/PLF/WESTES – Full Planning Permission

Erection of Conservatory to rear at 25 The Meadows, South Cave for Mr and Mrs Richardson-Medd. Cllr Scott proposed that the Parish Council raise no objection as the application has no adverse effect on the property, neighbouring properties or the street scene, seconded Cllr Turner, All in favour.

 

1381    Trees

             Applications:

(i)App 5095 (S211) – fell a tree at Cravens, East Lodge Ride, South Cave. Cllr Marsh proposed that the Parish Council defer to the opinion of the ERYC Tree Officer, seconded Cllr Scott, vote: 7 in favour 1 against.

Decisions:

(i)App 5045 (S211) – prune and fell trees at 2 Church Hill, South Cave – permission granted.

 

Meeting closed at 7:45pm

 

 

Signed…………………………

Chairman