South Cave Parish Council

 

Planning Meeting 5th March 2007

 

The Planning Meeting of South Cave Parish Council took place in the School Hall, Church Street, South Cave at 7.00pm.

 

Present:            Cllrs Turner, Mann, Scott, Lenton, Harrison, Marsh, Mrs Manley (Chair) Mrs Barnett and Mrs Binns

                        Mrs K Richmond – Clerk

                        24 Members of the Public

                       

1382  Apologies for absence

Absent: Cllrs Hardy and Wright

Apologies from: Ward Cllr Gill

 

1383   Approval of Previous Meeting's Minutes

The minutes of the meeting of 29th January 2007, with the addition of minute references, were signed as a true and correct record proposed Cllr Mann, seconded Cllr Mrs Binns, All in favour.

 

1384   Declarations of Interest

Cllr Mrs Binns declared a personal interest in minute reference: 1387(i) due to acquaintanceship

Cllr Mrs Manley declared a personal interest in minute reference: 1387(ii) due to living on the same street as the application

Cllr Turner declared a personal interest in minute reference: 1387 (i), (iii), and (iv) due to acquaintanceship, and due to living on the same street as the application (i)

Cllr Lenton declared a prejudicial interest in minute reference: 1387 (ii) due to living in close proximity to the application

Cllr Harrison declared a prejudicial interest in minute reference: 1387 (ii) due to friendship

Cllr Mann declared a prejudicial interest in minute reference: due to close acquaintanceship/friendship

Cllr Scott declared a prejudicial interest in minute reference: 1387 (iv) due to close acquaintanceship/friendship

 

1385    Correspondence

(i)To consider the appeal to Planning Inspectorate: 06/06662/PLF – two dwellings at 91 Beverley Road, South Cave. Cllr Marsh proposed that no further comment be made as recommendations will be forwarded to the Planning Inspectorate, seconded Cllr Mrs Barnett, All in favour.

(ii)To consider the appeal to Planning Inspectorate: 06/03228/PLF – retention of boundary fence at 17 Wesley Close, South Cave. Cllr Turner proposed that no further comment be made as recommendations will be forwarded to the Planning Inspectorate, seconded Cllr Lenton, All in favour.

(iii)The Council noted Planning Inspectorate appeal decision: 05/05741/OUT – dwelling at 55 Water Lane, South Cave – appeal dismissed

(iv)Councillors noted a letter from ERYC Head of Planning & Development Control regarding contributions to Open Play Space

 

 

Initialled………..

(v)The Council noted withdrawal of 06/09142/STPLF – changing facilities and football pitches at Bull Field.

 

1386    Decisions made by the East Riding of Yorkshire Council

(i)DC/06/03834/PLF – Full Planning Permission

Conversion of outbuildings to 3 office suites, 3 holiday cottages, 2 dwellings with workshops and agricultural building at Foxhouse Farm, Drewton for Mr C Taylor – Refused (NObj)

(ii)DC/06/03835/PLF – Full Planning Permission

Change of use from farm buildings to farm shop, cafι, conference and ancillary accommodation and construction of means of vehicular access at Kettlethorpe Farm, Drewton for Mr C Taylor – Refused (NObj)

(iii)DC/06/08453/REG3 – Regulation 3

New doorway to give access to old kitchen block at South Cave Church of England Primary School, Church Street, South Cave for East Riding of Yorkshire Council – Approved with conditions (NObj)

(iv)DC/06/09095/PLF – Full Planning Permission

Erection of double garage incorporating a flat following demolition of existing garage at 22 Station Road, South Cave for Mr and Mrs Haigh – Refused (Obj)

(v)DC/06/09492/PLF – Full Planning Permission

Erection of a detached dwelling and garage at Bramblewood Nursery, Stonepit Road, South Cave for Mr and Mrs Hill – Refused (RR)

(vi)DC/06/10006/PLF – Full Planning Permission

Erection of one dormer bungalow with integral garage at land  south east of 72 Beverley Road, South Cave for Alliance General Property Developments – Refused (NObj)

(vii)DC/07/00171/PLF – Full Planning Permission

Erection of conservatory to rear at 25 The Meadows, South Cave for Mr and Mrs Richardson-Medd – Approved with conditions (NObj)

 

1387    Current plans to consider

(i)DC/06/09953/PLF/WESTES – Full Planning Permission

Erection of 1 single storey dwelling and 1 two storey dwelling following demolition of existing sheds and conversion and alterations to existing shed to form single storey dwelling (amended scheme 06/06945/PLF)(Amended Scheme) at 48 West End, South Cave for Rok Design & Build. Cllr Lenton proposed that the Parish Council recommend refusal of this application as the two storey dwelling would create overshadowing and overlooking on surrounding properties, and would have an adverse effect on the street scene, and that there are considerable concerns regarding access to and from the site from Barnards Drive, seconded Cllr Mrs Binns, vote: 6 in favour 3 against.

Cllrs Harrison and Lenton declared a prejudicial interest in the following item, and so left the meeting and took no part in the discussion or the vote.

(ii)DC/06/09959/PLF/WESTESJC1 – Full Planning Permission

Erection of dwelling following the demolition of existing dwelling (re-submission of 06/05263/PLF)-amended plans at 38 Northfield Close, South Cave for Mr and Mrs Dearnley. Cllr Marsh proposed that the Parish Council recommend refusal of this application on the grounds that as there is no significant change to the amended plans it remains overdevelopment of the site, and due to its dominance would overshadow the adjacent bungalow, and that it would have an adverse effect on the street scene, seconded Cllr Scott, All in favour.

(iii)DC/07/00485/PLF/WESTES – Full Planning Permission

Erection of single storey extension at rear at 28 Water Lane, South Cave for J Fordon.

 

 

Initialled……….

 Cllr Lenton proposed that no objections be raised as the application has no adverse effect on the property, neighbouring properties or the street scene, seconded Cllr Scott, All in favour.

Cllrs Scott and Mann declared a prejudicial interest in the following item and left the meeting taking no part in the discussion or the vote.

(iv)DC/07/00631/PLF/WESTES – Full Planning Permission

Erection of single storey extensions to side and to include solar panels at front at 19 Rawdale Close, South Cave for Mr Bolton. Cllr Marsh proposed that the Parish Council recommend refusal of this application on the grounds that it would have an adverse effect on the neighbouring property and the street scene, seconded Cllr Harrison, vote: 5 in favour 2 against. It was also noted that the plans were slightly misleading.

(v)DC/07/00710/PLF/WESTES – Full Planning Permission

Erection of single storey extension to side to provide ground and first floor accommodation and construction of dormer window to front at 1 First Lane, South Cave for C Waudby. Cllr Scott proposed that no objection be raised as there would be no adverse effect on the property, neighbouring properties or the street scene, or the character and appearance of the Conservation Area, seconded Cllr Turner, All in favour.

 

1388    Trees

             Applications:

(i)App No. 5126(S211) – fell 2 cherry trees at The Hollies, Bacchus Lane, South Cave. Cllr Marsh proposed that no objection be raised regarding the removal of these two trees, but would like to see replacements in a more suitable location, seconded Cllr Mrs Manley, All in favour.

Decisions:

(i)App No. 5020 (TPO) – fell three trees at 23 Wesley Close, South Cave – permission refused.

 

1389    Other Parish Council Matters

(i)Having read through the Department of Communities and Local Government amendments to the Model Code of Conduct for Local Authority Members, Cllr Mrs Manley proposed that as Councillors had no objections to the amendments, no comments be forwarded to the DCLG, seconded Cllr Marsh, All in favour.

 

Meeting closed at 9:00pm

 

 

Signed…………………………

Chairman